Tuesday, January 10, 2017

The Application of Will

Every day offers up a multitude of opportunities to exercise our will both in the avoidance of what is bad and the movement towards that which is good. With the new year, I am thinking of health and how I might apply my will towards its improvement. On the physical side, we can exercise and diet. On the mental side, we can work towards using our time to improve our minds so that we can see the world as it is. No easy task.

Since I am on this path to learn and use Stoicism to improve my mental health, it only makes sense that I use it to improve my physical heath. Exercise seems the easier of the two because it seems more straightforward. I can take walks, run, use my exercise bike, lift weights, etc. It's kind of a do or don't do each day as in: rode exercise bike for 30 minutes. It's simply a matter of doing it or not doing it. 

Diet feels like the more complex because whether I am dieting or not, if I even want to call it a diet, I eat every day. In other words, we are all on a diet however we want to construct that diet. Then there are the temporary diets we all have pursued to achieve some weight goal. I am going to control the types of foods I eat for three months until I lose 15 pounds. We know how that works. If we are dedicated, we lose the 15 pounds and then, if we are like most of us, we gain them all back and then some. A couple of years ago I read the Gary Taubes book, Why We Get Fat, and just this week completed The Case Against Sugar. I thought both of them were excellent. I also got to see a Gary Taubes' lecture based upon his study of the research on sugar and the sugar industry. I highly recommend both of these books. What am I getting at? In considering both of these books, I have decided to undertake a unique diet that I am calling the Stoic Diet. In thinking about this, I should mention a third book, Michael Pollan's Food Rules. Pollan's book perhaps offers the best guidance, but I mention Taubes' work because he is the one that got me thinking about this more deeply. He built up my anger towards the food industry and the way we eat today.


Farmers Market in Ecuador
In taking another look at Pollan's book: eat food that you can identify in just a word: chicken, broccoli, eggs, carrots, apples, onions, etc. Avoid all processed foods. Avoid sugar, which if you are avoiding processed foods should be quite easy. If you have to read a label to figure out what something is, don't buy it. In fact, if there is a label or brand on a food item, avoid it. I fully realize there are issues with our meat, but I am not going to insist on organic because I can't afford it. Here is what I am thinking, don't eat anything Epictetus would not have recognized. He lived from  50 AD to 135 AD. Based upon that, I think it's a sure bet he likely didn't eat 99% of the items I will find in a modern grocery store. This will not be about weight loss, although I suspect that will be one of the results along with simply feeling better.

This is about health. We simply weren't meant to eat the way we do today. We weren't meant to drink sugar water. We weren't meant to eat boxes of industrial food made with ingredients we can't even pronounce. The identifying of the things I should not eat will be easy: if there is a brand on it, if it was made in a factory, if it has an expiration date a year in the future, don't eat it. It's not food.

So the application of will here is to eat the right thing based upon a simple rule: What did Epictetus Eat?


Monday, January 9, 2017

The Daily Stoic

My wife and I have started the year reading "The Daily Stoic" by Ryan Holiday. This work basically does what I have been trying to do over the past few months--taking quotes from various Stoic writers and offering up commentary to, hopefully, make the quote more approachable. We are on January 9th with a full year of entries to look forward to reading and, more importantly, incorporating into our lives. While it certainly is intimidating to have these "365 meditations on wisdom, perseverance, and the art of living" out there in book form, it can't but make us all that much more wise. If you have a chance, get this book.





Monday, December 19, 2016

The Wise Fool

But it is impossible to move some of the men of to-day, so that I think that I know now what I did not know before, the meaning of the familiar saying, 'A fool is not to be persuaded nor broken of his folly.' May it never be my lot to have for friend a wise fool: nothing is more difficult to handle.
Discourses of Epictetus
Book 2, Chapter 15

Ahh, the wise fool. How often in our daily lives--personally and through various media--do we encounter that person who thinks they are the guardians of the truth. We can see they are intelligent, well spoken, well read even, but they press their belief in some false idea that has been tested and found false over and over again. 

In a video, Slavoj Žižek quotes a communist commissar insisting that communism failed in the Soviet Union because it was never really implemented, that it had been corrupted by Stalin. And with the same reasoning, a staunch capitalist is shown offering the same logic following yet another massive economic collapse. He insists the failure of capitalism was a result of it being corrupted by too much government interference; that pure capitalism, like pure communism, has never really been tried. Both people represent the wise fool--men of great intellect who continue to cling to false ideas. 

These are world changing ideas that millions still cling to, which brings up the greater point: what ideas do we, as individuals, have that are false, that are damaging to our ability to lead good, meaningful lives. Do we overvalue the opinion of others? Do we give meaning to things rather than to people? Do we try to make ourselves "better" by buying some consumer product rather than working on the only thing that can make us better: our minds. Are we valuing the wrong things perhaps making false connections: money leading to love, or travel to enlightenment, or thinness to happiness. I'm not providing any answers here, but rather offering up the idea that we should examine our fool's wisdom.
When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?
John Maynard Keynes




Friday, December 16, 2016

Actions

That is why philosophers enjoin upon us 'not to be content with learning only, but to add practice as well and then training.'
Discourses of Epictetus

Just as an apple on a shelf means nothing to your body until it has been eaten, philosophy means nothing until it results in a change in our habits, in our ways of perceiving the world and the actions that result from that perception. I have a bookshelf of unread books that are merely stacks of paper until they are read and produce some change in my mind. That is not to say that knowledge for its own sake is not a good, but that philosophy should be like the food we eat, it should become a part of our lives and lead to a change in how we perceive the world and take action. The eaten apple becomes a part of our bone and blood so should the philosophy we take on as a guide change the way we perceive the world and alter the actions we take.
What you store away you have at hand and can show to others at will, but it does you no good except for the mere name of having it.
Discourses of Epictetus 

If I am to call myself a Stoic, I should keep it to myself and allow my actions to represent who I am rather than the spewing of words about this or that writing by some ancient. Firstly, I don't know all the words, and can only put forth here what I have spread before me in an open book with the words underlined. Do those underlined words mean anything if they are not reflected in my daily actions and thoughts. That's important. For as much as our way of interacting with the world should drive towards right action, our thoughts should be directed by our rational mind, our will. It is the way we filter the world to draw false conclusions that really get us into trouble. We draw conclusions that are not supported by the facts, by reality as it exists.
Poorly treated things tend to break.
Yesterday, for example, I put up some Christmas lights and ran into a few problems that resulted in an outpouring of expletives and threats of violence against the retail industry, lighting manufacturers, incompetent 
engineers, and the very concept of Christmas. But if I think logically, and look at the facts around my treatment of that string of lights, I am to blame. Did I not bundle them up without any thought for the delicate wires that connect the lights together? Did I not throw them into the corner of the garage with no consideration of their future use? Is it any wonder that their delicate wires would break and stop working? So with many things: careers, marriages, friendships, family, etc. We have to take care of those things we want to continue functioning. All of them are delicate things with connections that must be maintained and you can't just go to the hardware store to replace what no longer works. 

So we have to put our reading and thinking into action in activities both trivial and essential. When things go wrong, more often than not it is some action we did not take. Keep well.

Thursday, December 15, 2016

Wasting Time

Yes, do just that, dear Lucilius: liberate yourself, and gather and save up time which until now was being taken from you by force or stealth or simply slipping away unnoticed. Convince yourself that the situation is as I describe it; some periods of time are snatched from us, some are stolen, and some simply seep away. Yet the most shameful loss is the loss due to carelessness. Indeed, if you consider things attentively, the greatest part of life slips away in failure, a great part in futility, and all of it in distraction. 
Selected Letters
Lucius Annaeus Seneca

What a tragedy it is to go through life and at the end, when there is little left, start to see how precious it is. It's like winning a lottery, and then when there is only $10,000 left starting to be thrifty. It's too late. We only have one precious life to live, but how much of our time is wasted in shopping, trivial entertainments, and other meaningless activities? Do we really have so much life that we can spend an entire day binge watching some mediocre television show? Since our lives are time, time should be that most precious thing we preserve and consume in the pursuit of meaningful activities? So then the bigger question becomes: What is a meaningful activity? One that makes you a better person, one that takes you closer to leading a good life of virtue. Watching 5 seasons of Breaking Bad in a week is not going to move anyone towards that goal. Spending three nights a week in a pub drinking with your "drinking buddies" is not going to help. 

How is it some have, with the same amount of time or even much less, produced so much? It is as if they lived a dozen lives compared to the little I have done. I suspect, through an act of pure will, they made a decision to use their time wisely, to dedicate it to activities that would amount to something meaningful. I don't mean making money or achieving great power, but rather being engaged in something that is good, that adds up to something. So there is the bigger question: What constitutes a meaningful life? That's a big one! 

We should look at our time as our most valuable resource to not be wasted. And each of us knows when we are wasting our time, when we are engaged in something that, in the end, adds nothing to our lives but a cloudy head with no real memories. Live well. 

Confession: Given the lack of entries on this blog over the past few weeks, as well as no meaningful updates to www.stoicfreedom.com, it's obvious I have been wasting my time. Yes, I did spend time on completing another painting, and starting a third one, but other than that the past few weeks have been a blur. Time to sort out what are meaningful activities and what are meaningless. Don't "kill time" use it to some good purpose. Since one way of measuring progress is to show results, and I have offered up the idea that painting is a meaningful activity, here is the second painting I have completed. Keep well.

The Road (24" x 30")

Monday, October 24, 2016

Focus on Your Strengths

If you try to act a part beyond your powers, you not only disgrace yourself in it, but you neglect the part which you could have filled with success.
The Manual of Epictetus

How often in life are we presented with choices that take us down different paths? On the one hand, there is something we know we can do, and on the other there is the challenging opportunity that will stretch us and push us but require that we become someone we are not. The self-help, success culture of today would suggest we go for that thing that challenges everything about us rather than pursue the thing that aligns with who we are. Is it wise to try to become something you are not? 
I say, beware of all enterprises that require new clothes, and not rather a new wearer of clothes. If there is not a new man, how can the new clothes be made to fit? If you have any enterprise before you, try it in your old clothes.
Walden
Henry David Thoreau

I can look at a man and, for whatever reason, desire those things he has or look with envy at his accomplishments or good fortune, but in the end I am also wishing I was someone other than who I am. We should work with the clay we have rather than wish we were made of different clay. Others have their own natures and good fortune that brings them their own burdens and freedoms, but in the end we are stuck with our own clay that can be molded, but not turned into something it is not. We all have to come to understand our nature and mold how we live to that nature so we can accomplish our true life's work. Keep well.

Friday, October 7, 2016

Fear

What you must practice and have at command is to know what you ought to approach with confidence, and what with caution; all that is beyond the control of the will with confidence and what is dependent on the will with caution.
Discourses of Epictetus 

The above quote, to me at least, is stating things in the opposite way I generally think. I tend to fear the unknown, fearing those things I can't control, but am confident about those things around me that are in my control. But, if I think honestly about it, it's clear we are our primary enemy. Looking back over my own life, any real damage that was done to me, whether physical, mental or financial, was the result of poor reasoning and a misapplied will. We are the villain we have to fear, not the villain in the street. Yes, there are horrible things coming to all of us, but most of those things are beyond our control so should not be feared. What we should fear are those things that are within our control. 

How do we come to avoid those things that are damaging to us? By using the one power that makes us human: our reasoning ability, our ability to stop, think and determine where we have control and where we do not. 

If I think back to problems that have occurred in my life, following the roots to the seed that grew the weed, I find that I planted the seed. At some point I made a choice based upon poor logic or, usually, no logic at all. For example, we spend hours thinking about the upcoming election, but ignore the things within our own houses that we should be working through. This isn't about being "happy," it's about not wasting our lives obsessing over things completely out of our control. For example, I used to read a lot about Nazi Germany and the Holocaust based upon being part German and living in Germany as a child. Historically, not to be trivial, it's an amazing, well documented piece of history. When I lived in Germany, I still saw the scars of war--bomb craters in the woods and ruins. But really, why read a dozen books about it when one would have done the trick. Why fill my mind with those grim stories and images of death and destruction. On a much smaller scale, I think we spend a lot of time with our own tragic stories going round and round in our heads reliving some childhood sadness, adult disappointment or worse. At some point, using our own reasoning power, we have to clear the shelf of those memories. Pull the weed.


This is what we have to fear: the demon within us that will push us to pursue actions that lead to an empty life built upon delusions. In the words of Seneca: A man is as miserable as he thinks he is. 

If we work to apply reason to our actions and thoughts, we can tame the beast. Keep well.